Fair4All...

A QUESTION, A MANTRA & A HOPE - FOR ALL...

What's "fair" really?
Is 'fairness' about equality, justice, mercy?
Who is fair? Is it personal, legal or universal?
Or is it just a weather condition - one that life is certainly not?

Friday, May 30, 2008

Who Do WE Execute? Why Them? Fair?

Folks often have a dim view of lawyers, unless you don't have one when you're in trouble. And look at who most often does not have any, adequate, consistent public defenders: poor people get lousy lawyers. Then, they die. Talk about making a difference!

Successful Death Penalty appeals showed that the problem with the sentencing was not the method of execution — the issue ruled on by the Supreme Court last month — but instead bad legal help.

“All these states are gearing up to start executing people again, and nobody seems to be concerned about the systemic problems like lousy lawyers,” was the recent ACLU winning argument.

See more about this ongoing unfairness at:
http://www.nytimes.com/2008/05/07/us/07execute.html?_r=1&hp&oref=slogin

And let me know what we can do about it?

Thursday, May 29, 2008

What's a fair price for one life?

Given the rash of natural disasters in the last few years, and the generous outpouring of donations to victims in New Orleans, Indonesia, Burma and China, its remarkable to see economists attempt to parce the value of one life.

One method, say the authors of Freakonomics, is to look at the amount of money donated to support those causes, and how it has diminished per capita over time. See the NYTimes article here:

http://freakonomics.blogs.nytimes.com/2008/05/13/how-pure-is-your-altruism/

There's also another, more direct "price point" set for one human life as a result of insurance claims for those disasters and others like the Lockerbee airplane bombing settlement.

I'll look for more info on those to seed this economic / valuation of life, and to question if it's fair or not.